Colonials - Nickels - Long Island Rare Coins & Currency
Start typing to see products you are looking for.
  • Menu
  • Browse Categories

Shopping cart

Close
FREE SHIPPING FOR ALL ORDERS OVER $1,000!
Menu
Start typing to see products you are looking for.
Wishlist 0
0 item(s) / $0.00

Show sidebar
Show 12 22 44 All
    1914-D 5C Buffalo NGC MS64 CAC
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1914-D 5C Buffalo NGC MS64 CAC

    $850.00
    Super Original!
    Add to Cart
    1917 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1917 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65

    $500.00
    Add to Cart
    1919-S 5C Buffalo NGC AU58
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1919-S 5C Buffalo NGC AU58

    $625.00
    Add to Cart
    1924-S 5C Buffalo PCGS XF40
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1924-S 5C Buffalo PCGS XF40

    $600.00
    Reverse Softly Struck!
    Add to Cart
    1931-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1931-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65

    $245.00
    Add to Cart
    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS65
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS65

    $105.00
    From a Gem Roll! Super Fresh! Great Lustre! Besides this coin, we have additional coins in this grade!
    Add to Cart
    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS66
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS66

    $200.00
    From a Gem Roll! Super Fresh with Great Lustre! Besides this coin, we have one additional coin in this grade!
    Add to Cart
    1936 S/S 5C Buffalo FS-501 NGC VF Details Cleaned
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1936 S/S 5C Buffalo FS-501 NGC VF Details Cleaned

    $50.00
    Add to Cart
    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS65
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS65

    $75.00
    From a Gem Roll! Super Brilliant! Besides this coin, we have two additional coins in this grade!
    Add to Cart
    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS66
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS66

    $100.00
    From a Gem Roll! Super Brilliant! Besides this coin, we have additional coins in this grade!
    Add to Cart
    1937-D 5C 3 Legs Buffalo FS-901 PCGS VF20
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1937-D 5C 3 Legs Buffalo FS-901 PCGS VF20

    $725.00
    Add to Cart
    1937-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65
    Quick View
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare

    1937-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65

    $80.00
    1937-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65
    Add to Cart
    Scroll To Top

    #title#

    		#price#
    		×