Colonials - Nickels - Long Island Rare Coins & Currency
Start typing to see products you are looking for.
  • Menu
  • Browse Categories

Shopping cart

Close
FREE SHIPPING FOR ALL ORDERS OVER $1,000!
Menu
Start typing to see products you are looking for.
Wishlist 0
0 item(s) / $0.00

Show sidebar
Show 12 22 44 All
    1913 5C Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66 CAC
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1913 5C Type 1 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS66 CAC

    $500.00
    1913-D 5C Type 2 Buffalo NGC MS64 CAC
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1913-D 5C Type 2 Buffalo NGC MS64 CAC

    $775.00
    1913-S 5C Type 2 Buffalo NGC MS63
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1913-S 5C Type 2 Buffalo NGC MS63

    $1,100.00
    1913-S 5C Type 2 Buffalo Mint Error PCGS AU55 Disc Clip @ 1:00
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1913-S 5C Type 2 Buffalo Mint Error PCGS AU55 Disc Clip @ 1:00

    $675.00
    1914-D 5C Buffalo NGC MS64 CAC
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1914-D 5C Buffalo NGC MS64 CAC

    $850.00
    1915 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1915 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65

    $525.00
    1917 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1917 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65

    $500.00
    1919-S 5C Buffalo NGC AU58
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1919-S 5C Buffalo NGC AU58

    $625.00
    1924 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1924 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65

    $700.00
    1924-S 5C Buffalo PCGS XF40
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1924-S 5C Buffalo PCGS XF40

    $600.00
    1931-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1931-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65

    $245.00
    1935-D 5C Buffalo PCGS MS64
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1935-D 5C Buffalo PCGS MS64

    $135.00
    1936 5C Buffalo NGC MS66
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1936 5C Buffalo NGC MS66

    $110.00
    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS65

    $105.00
    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS66
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1936-D 5C Buffalo CACG MS66

    $200.00
    1936 S/S 5C Buffalo FS-501 NGC VF Details Cleaned
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1936 S/S 5C Buffalo FS-501 NGC VF Details Cleaned

    $50.00
    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS65

    $75.00
    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS66
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1937 5C Buffalo CACG MS66

    $100.00
    1937-D 5C ANACS VG8 3 Leg
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1937-D 5C ANACS VG8 3 Leg

    $495.00
    1937-D 5C 3 Legs Buffalo FS-901 PCGS VF20
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1937-D 5C 3 Legs Buffalo FS-901 PCGS VF20

    $725.00
    1937-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1937-S 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65

    $80.00
    1938-D 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65
    Add to wishlist
    Add to compare
    Quick View
    Add to Cart

    1938-D 5C Buffalo PCGS MS65

    $120.00
    Scroll To Top

    #title#

    		#price#
    		×